Add data availability statement guard#375
Conversation
|
Reviewer-ready checkpoint for /claim #12. This PR is open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, Bounty claim labeled, and the body contains /claim #12. Scope remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard: availability sections, repository accessions, license checks, reviewer-only link freshness, collaborator approvals, and export blocking/remediation decisions with synthetic data and demo evidence. |
|
Visibility update after PR #415: this existing Scope remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard, separate from the newer local-cache privacy slice. PR #375 covers availability sections, repository accessions, license checks, reviewer-only access freshness, collaborator approvals, and export blocking/remediation decisions with synthetic data and demo evidence. I do not see a contributor-side blocker for review/reward decision on this PR. |
|
Status refresh after issue #12 PR #418 was submitted: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for the existing data-availability statement guard submission. Scope remains distinct from clipboard/import provenance and no code changes are needed unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after issue #12 PR #420 was submitted: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for the existing data-availability statement guard submission. Scope remains distinct from notebook output reproducibility and no code changes are needed unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after the latest PR #420 activity on issue #12: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for the existing data-availability statement guard submission. Scope remains distinct from notebook output reproducibility; no code changes are needed unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after newer same-issue #12 activity. Re-verified now: this PR is open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. The scope remains the data-availability statement guard: required availability sections, repository accessions, license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, export blockers, and reviewer-ready remediation evidence before final manuscript export. This is distinct from the newer comment anchor drift, notebook output reproducibility, and clipboard/import provenance slices. No implementation changes are needed from my side unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after the new same-issue PR #436 activity: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. The submitted scope remains the data-availability statement guard: required availability sections, repository accessions, license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, export blockers, and reviewer-ready remediation evidence. This is distinct from collaborative find/replace safety, comment-anchor drift, notebook output reproducibility, clipboard/import provenance, local-cache privacy, LaTeX macro safety, suggestion provenance, and the other #12 slices. |
|
Status refresh after the newer same-issue PR #444 activity: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. The submitted scope remains the data-availability statement guard: required availability sections, repository accessions, license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, export blockers, and reviewer-ready remediation evidence before final manuscript export. This is distinct from PR #444's private-comment export guard, plus the collaborative find/replace safety, comment-anchor drift, notebook output reproducibility, clipboard/import provenance, local-cache privacy, LaTeX macro safety, suggestion provenance, and other #12 slices. |
|
Status refresh after the newer same-issue PR #418 hardening activity: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. The submitted scope remains the data-availability statement guard: required availability sections, repository accessions, license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, export blockers, and reviewer-ready remediation evidence before final manuscript export. This is distinct from PR #418's collaborative clipboard import/provenance guard and hardening update, PR #444's private-comment export guard, PR #436's collaborative find/replace safety guard, PR #431's comment anchor drift gate, PR #420's notebook output reproducibility guard, local-cache privacy, LaTeX macro safety, suggestion provenance, and other #12 editor slices. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after the newer same-issue PR #418 hardening pass: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. The submitted scope remains the data-availability statement guard: required availability sections, repository accessions, license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, export blockers, and reviewer-ready remediation evidence before final manuscript export. This is distinct from PR #418's collaborative clipboard import/provenance guard and hardening pass for private-reference marker redaction, PR #444's private-comment export guard, PR #436's collaborative find/replace safety guard, PR #431's comment anchor drift gate, PR #420's notebook output reproducibility guard, local-cache privacy, LaTeX macro safety, suggestion provenance, and other #12 editor slices. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after the newer same-issue PR #459 activity: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. The submitted scope remains the data-availability statement guard: required data/code availability sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access link freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes before final manuscript export. PR #459 appears to add a separate section lock/autosave auditor for non-owner edits inside hard-locked sections, expired lock leases, unauthorized unlocks, cursor presence in locked regions, offline lock conflicts, autosave gaps, missing version parents, restore overwrite risks, and named-version dirty-state issues. That is adjacent, but PR #375 is still the prior data-availability statement export-readiness layer for this issue. |
|
Status refresh after the newer same-issue PR #469 activity: PR #375 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. The submitted scope remains the data-availability statement guard: required data/code availability sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access link freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes before final manuscript export. PR #469 appears to add a separate hotkey scope guard for browser shortcuts, notebook execution collisions, locked-section shortcut mutations, focus guards, shared-state action audit events, and permission bypasses. That is adjacent collaborative-editor interaction safety, but PR #375 remains the prior data-availability statement export-readiness layer for this issue. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after new same-issue PR #474 activity on issue #12. This existing submission remains PR #375, open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, and tied to the Pending USD 700 Algora claim: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Maintainer review target remains the data-availability statement guard implemented here: required availability sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification notes, embargo expiry, and deterministic reviewer-ready artifacts. |
|
Visibility refresh after newer issue #12 attempt activity: this PR remains my active claimed issue #12 submission. Verified now: open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, This PR's reviewed scope remains the data-availability statement guard for the real-time collaborative research editor: availability sections, repository accessions, citation anchors, license acceptability, reviewer-only link freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes. |
|
Visibility refresh after the newer same-issue PR #479 claim registration. This existing submission remains PR #375, open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, Maintainer review target remains the data-availability statement guard implemented here: required availability sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes. That scope is separate from PR #479's journal-style conformance/export-readiness slice. |
|
Visibility refresh after later same-issue PR #393 activity on May 29. This existing submission remains PR #375, open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, Maintainer review target remains the data-availability statement guard implemented here: availability sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes. That scope is separate from PR #393's collaborative LaTeX macro safety guard. |
|
Visibility refresh after later same-issue PR #486 activity on May 29. This existing submission remains PR #375, open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, Maintainer review target remains the data-availability statement guard implemented here: availability sections, repository accessions, citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes before final manuscript export. That scope is separate from PR #486's collaborative section-lock arbitration guard. |
|
Visibility refresh after the newer same-issue PR #492 claim registration. This existing submission remains PR #375, open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, Maintainer review target remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard: required data/code sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access link freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes before final export. PR #492 appears to add a separate editor suggestion provenance guard for tracked-change authorship and accepted-change lineage; PR #375 remains the prior availability-statement export readiness layer. |
|
Visibility refresh after PR #418's newer hardening pass for imported table-cell local/private path scanning and redaction. My existing issue #12 submission remains PR #375: #375 Current status re-verified now: PR #375 is open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, includes Scope reminder for review: PR #375 is the collaborative data-availability statement guard for the real-time research editor. It gates final manuscript export when data/code availability statement evidence is not review-ready, checking required data/code sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access link freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes. This remains separate from PR #418's collaborative clipboard/file-import provenance and table-cell redaction hardening, PR #492's suggestion provenance guard, PR #486's section-lock arbitration guard, and other adjacent #12 editor slices. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after PR #418's newer hardening pass for missing or unrecognized source-trust metadata. My existing issue #12 submission remains PR #375: #375 Current status re-verified now: PR #375 is open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, includes Scope reminder for review: PR #375 is the collaborative data-availability statement guard for the real-time research editor. It gates final manuscript export when data/code availability statement evidence is not review-ready, checking required data/code sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes. This remains separate from PR #418's clipboard/file-import provenance guard and its duplicate-anchor, private-reference redaction, table-cell path scanning, formula-cell handling, and source-trust metadata gates. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #12 competitor PR #418 activity. This PR #375 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-listed, and claim-marked for issue #12. Scope remains distinct: data availability statement readiness before public release, including dataset/software/preservation requirements, DOI/URL accessibility, embargo handling, access restrictions, sensitive-use flags, and deterministic release/hold remediation artifacts. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #12 PR #418 later than my last status. This PR #375 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. It is tied to the Pending USD 700 Algora claim: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Scope remains distinct: PR #375 is the collaborative data-availability statement guard for final manuscript export readiness, covering required data/code sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes. PR #418 remains a separate clipboard/file-import provenance guard for duplicate anchors, private-reference redaction, table-cell path scanning, source-trust metadata, unsupported channels, attestation, and stale review metadata. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG same-issue PR #418 updated at 2026-05-30T01:41:13Z. PR #375 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, Algora bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. No CI checks are configured for this branch. Scope remains distinct: PR #375 gates final manuscript export on data/code availability statement evidence, repository accessions, citation anchors, license acceptability, reviewer-only link freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes. PR #418 remains a separate clipboard/file-import provenance guard before collaborative insertion. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #12 PR #418 later than my last status. This PR #375 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. It is tied to the Pending USD 700 Algora claim: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Scope remains distinct: PR #375 is the collaborative data-availability statement guard for final manuscript export readiness. PR #418 remains a separate clipboard/file-import provenance guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #12 competitor PR activity from yunrongy424-oss PR #444. This PR #375 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. It is tied to the Pending USD 700 Algora claim: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Scope remains distinct: collaborative data-availability statement evidence for final manuscript export readiness. PR #444 is a separate private comment export guard, and PR #418 remains a separate clipboard/file-import provenance guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #12 PR #418 again with lowercase Windows user-path redaction hardening. This PR #375 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. It is tied to the Pending USD 700 Algora claim: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Scope remains distinct: collaborative data-availability statement evidence for final manuscript export readiness. PR #418 remains a separate clipboard/file-import provenance guard focused on source/attestation/path-sanitization safety before collaborative insertion. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #12 PR #418 again with forward-slash Windows user-path redaction hardening. This PR #375 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. It is tied to the Pending USD 700 Algora claim: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Scope remains distinct: collaborative data-availability statement evidence for final manuscript export readiness. PR #418 remains a separate clipboard/file-import provenance guard focused on source/attestation/path-sanitization safety before collaborative insertion. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #12 activity from @KoiosSG in PR #418 (collaborative clipboard import guard). PR #375 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for #12. Algora reward link remains indexed: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Scope remains the data availability statement guard, separate from PR #418's collaborative clipboard import guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #12 activity from @Entr0zy and @KoiosSG, including PRs #498, #501, #502, and #418. PR #375 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. Its Algora claim remains Pending for USD 700: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Scope remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard for final manuscript export readiness. It is separate from the newer footnote export, chat mention scope, editor mode toggle, and clipboard import guards. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #12 PR activity from @codeaustral-oss / PR #303. PR #375 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. Its Algora claim remains Pending for USD 700: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ Scope remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard for final manuscript export readiness. It is separate from PR #303's collaborative task dependency guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #12 PR activity from @keon0711 / PR #514: #514 This PR #375 remains my active issue #12 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard, separate from PR #514's collaborative equation anchor integrity guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #12 PR updates from @Entr0zy: PR #498 and PR #502. This PR #375 remains my active issue #12 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the collaborative data availability statement guard, separate from PR #498's footnote/endnote export guard and PR #502's editor mode-toggle fidelity guard. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after the latest same-issue #12 PR updates from @Entr0zy:
This PR #375 remains my active issue #12 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the collaborative data availability statement guard, separate from PR #501's chat mention scope guard and PR #502's editor mode-toggle fidelity guard. |
|
Merge/reward readiness refresh for /claim #12. Current contributor-side status rechecked from the watcher:
Could a maintainer please review this PR for merge/reward decision, or point me to the exact change needed to unblock it? I can respond quickly. |
1 participant
/claim #12
Summary
Adds
collaborative-data-availability-statement-guard, a self-contained Real-time Collaborative Research Editor slice that gates final manuscript export when data/code availability statement evidence is not review-ready.The guard evaluates:
Non-overlap
This is intentionally separate from the existing and competing slices. It is not a reference-library merge guard, notification visibility guard, accessibility checker, presence privacy guard, evidence binding guard, or general embargo-release workflow. It focuses on availability-statement export readiness for a collaborative manuscript package.
Local validation
Run from
collaborative-data-availability-statement-guard/:npm run check npm test npm run demo npm run demo:videoAll four commands passed locally.
Reviewer artifacts
reports/summary.jsonreports/reviewer-packet.mdreports/summary.svgreports/demo.webmSafety
All data is synthetic. The module does not call GitHub, Zenodo, OSF, journal systems, identity services, storage APIs, email systems, or live manuscript export services. It does not include private manuscripts, credentials, human-subject records, or reviewer data.
Current status - 2026-05-30 01:00 IST
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #12 PR #418. PR #375 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, Algora-labeled, and distinct: it gates final manuscript export on data/code availability statement evidence, repository accessions, licenses, reviewer-only link freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, and unresolved availability comments. PR #418 remains a separate clipboard/file-import provenance guard before collaborative insertion.
Current status - 2026-05-30 02:17 IST
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #12 PR #418 again. PR #375 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, Algora-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12.
PR #375 remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard: required data/code sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes before final manuscript export.
PR #418 remains a separate collaborative clipboard/file-import provenance guard for duplicate anchors, private-reference redaction, table-cell path scanning, formula-cell handling, and source-trust metadata. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions.
Current status - 2026-05-30 02:49 IST
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #12 PR #418 later than my last status. PR #375 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, Algora-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12.
PR #375 remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard: required data/code sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes before final manuscript export.
PR #418 remains a separate collaborative clipboard/file-import provenance guard. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions.
Current status - 2026-05-30 12:06 IST
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #12 PR #418 later than my last PR-body status. PR #375 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #12. Its Algora claim remains Pending for USD 700: https://algora.io/claims/JXzZctN6u4EnVgcQ
PR #375 remains the collaborative data-availability statement guard for final manuscript export readiness: required data/code sections, repository accessions, statement citation anchors, dataset/code license acceptability, reviewer-only access freshness, de-identification evidence, collaborator approvals, blocking availability comments, and unmerged editor changes.
PR #418 remains a separate clipboard/file-import provenance guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions.