Troubles printing data

[alassaneg]

Hello,

First of all, thank you for your projects, it helps me a lot moving forward on my project.
Now, i'm having some issus printing data from my computer to the raspberry.
So, i've well followed the tutorial and my computer recognize the rasperry as a printer (in my case, i'm emulating a HP laserjet P1005).
When i launch the printing, the file goes to the printing queue and then nothing happens....I just receive the following characters : 12345x @pjl ENTER LANGUAGE=ACL (seems to be an hp command).
While testing this, did you have to send some kind of acknowledgment to the computer to start the printing?

Thank you in advance for your help.

[Raspberryy]

Hi,

If I remember correctly, I had similar issues with a different printer (Xerox maybe), when it was recognized correctly but wouldn't sent the print job. I never tried solving it. Also, I needed to send back data to PC. The original example of the gadget api contains a method for sending back data to the host (here).

If you really need to stick to the HP P1005 and keep the current driver you might want to use the USB traffic analyzer again: Start capturing traffic, connect a real HP P1005, send a very simple print job (empty page or one char) and check if your printer sends data on the BULK IN endpoint. If so, you can try copying that communication by sending the same data as the printer did. BUT this potentially requires an exact emulation of the original interface. The Raspberry Pi emulates an Endpoint 1 Bulk IN and Endpoint 1 Bulk OUT interface. If the original interface uses 1 Bulk OUT and 2 Bulk IN you might need to build your own version of the g_printer module (wouldn't want to that!).

If you have access to the computer the pi is connected to, you can also try changing the drivers manually. That gives you the ability to for example select the Generic Text-Only driver on Windows which makes it much easier to work with the received data.

If you don't need to emulate that exact printer, try different ones! The foomatic DB contains almost 4000 printers. The most models I got working were Ricoh Postscript printers. Check the Makefile for good examples.

It would be really cool if you can share the parameters for your HP LaserJet P1005 and any other printer you get working :)

Attached is a file which I got from a HP1220 emulation. maybe this helps.
hp1220_example.txt

[alassaneg]

Actually i don't have to stick with the HP 1005, i just took it randomly, but at the end i will have to stick with a HP or Epson printer. I just haven't found the parameters for the printers i want to emulate.

For now, i've tried to emulate 3 different model and i can't get them working so i'll try to emulate a ricoh one as you suggest.
And i need to get myself a HP printer so i can try to analyze the USB traffic, if i can't find the information online. And hopefully, i won't have to develop my own driver!
But i actually don't think that the printer needs to send data to the computer. For example, HP uses the PJL (printer job language) to allow ones developping it's own application to communicate with the printer and return datas are not mentionned in the manual so the problem seems to be somewhere else, but i'll confirm that once i have a printer.

And actually, the HP LaserJet P1005 parameters are already in the PNP file you provided, i took it from there.

Thank you for your answer, it really helps!

[Raspberryy]

How are you going to process the received print jobs? I found, that GhostPDL isn't an optimal solution for converting PCL, which HP printers are most likely to have. That is another reason why used Ricoh printers. The best HP printer I found was the HP 1220. GhostPDL was able to convert it to readable PDF, but not able to extract the text.

Also be sure you have the correct VendorID and ProductID. I am not 100% sure but I think you need to set the HEX parameters with uppercase letters. so for HP use idVendor=0x03F0 and not idVendor=0x03f0.

Again, if you have access to the Host, e.g. the computer the pi is connected to, you can simply change the drivers manually. That way you don't need to stick with PCL, ACL, EPS or ESC. I would suggest you use a PostScript printer if you want to extract data from the print jobs!

[alassaneg]

Actually, right now, i just want to check if i'm able to receive a print job whether it is PCL, ACL or anything else...So i'm not going to process anything right now.
But at the end, i'll most likely have to stick with ESC/P printers and i'm planning on processing the received print jobs with the following tool : https://github.com/receipt-print-hq/escpos-tools . I might adapt it to your code.

Got it regarding the uppercase letters, i'm already using them.

I didn't know that changing the driver was an option so thank you for the info. I thought that one printer could work with a unique driver : the vendor driver.

[Raspberryy]

If you connect the real printer you will of course need the actual driver. So, if you are planning to forward the print job to the real printer someday you might want to stick to the real driver.

Are you now able to emulate a printer and receive some data? I didn't quite catch that.

[alassaneg]

Right now, i'm just checking if the g_printer is working.
I've tried to emulate the Ricoh Aficio SP35010SF but still not able to receive the print job...
Could you tell me which printer you've used that work?

[Raspberryy]

All listed in the Makefile (except the Kyocera FS1020D) were detected by my Windows 10 PC. The Ricoh printers worked best.
Do you get any error message? Do you still only receive a few lines?

I mentioned this in a different Issue but maybe this is your problem as well: The printer.c contains functions for setting three parameters: Paper Loaded/Paper Out, Error/ No Error, and Selected / Not selected. The correct status is Selected, Paper Loaded, No Error. Confirm that this is the case for you by running emulatedprinter -get_status. Change values if needed (See emulatedprinter -h).

Whats your host? What are you using to print? What drivers are currently loaded? What do you receive?

[alassaneg]

I don't get any error messages.
Actually, i tried again and it seems to work well. I first tried to print this page but its a complicated one so i opened word and tried to print a single white page and it worked well, finally!

Now that the driver and the code are working, i need to get my self an ESC/P printer and it's pnpString (hard to find online so I might buy one).

I still need to figure out what is going on with these other printers. HP and epson don't mention any return values from the printer to the host in their commands reference manual...
I really appreciate your help.

[Raspberryy]

If you share I little mor of your setup, maybe we can help :) If you ever publish your project, keep me updated, I am really interested in seeing how people use this repo!

[alassaneg]

I finally got myself an epson TM-T88V printer.
For some reason, it doesn't have a pnp number. I didn't see it with usblyzer but i was able to get the vendor and product ID and after installing manually the driver, the printer work.
Then, when trying to emulate it, it's not working. Windows can see the emulated printer but it's considered as unavailable.
Actually the TM-T88V doesn't seem to act as a normal printer. When i plug it, the printer doesn't appear in the printer tree of the peripheral manager...
So the conclusion is that i don't think the gadget_printer driver can handle that POS printer.

[Raspberryy]

Thats weird :/ You can share the USBlyzer capture file, maybe I can help you :)

[alassaneg]

TM-88V_LOG.zip

The file is right here!

[Raspberryy]

Looks like the best solution is getting started on building your own version of the g_printer module. It looks quite similar to the emulated interface of the g_printer module (e.g. same Endpoints), but the interface descriptor is different. You might simply need to change bInterfaceClass and the bInterfaceSubClass for your version of the g_printer module. Sadly I never needed to build a custom version and currently I don't really have the time to get into this.

But hey, that might be a cool project!

[alassaneg]

That was my concern but anyway, i'll still have to give a try then!
I'll have to go deep in the g_printer and i'll try to modify it.

Thanks again for your help