Skip to content

Comments Homework 1 #1

@edufierro

Description

@edufierro
  1. Medal Counts over Time (7pt+2pt Bonus)

Usefulness: The graph with lines is really confussing. Bar graphs should be sorted. Doesn't really tell much about the medals over time.
Truthfulness: Ok.
Legibility: Too many lines in the last graph.
Self-contained: Impossibe to read ticks on first graph. Some of the graphs don't have good label titles. Neither graph has a title.
Design/Theme: Last graph has the best theming, though maybe change colors to make it more true.

4pts.


  1. Medal Counts adjusted by Population, GDP (6pt)

Non of the graphs have proper title, it's impossible to see what you're trying to express.
I'm not sure what you tried to expressed with the density graphs.
The polar coordinates is a really weird idea in this case. Graph doesn't say much, very hard to follow each country and what it represents.

3pts.


  1. Host Country Advantage (6pt)

The line graph is just unreadable. What it has to do with host country?
The second graph only represents when they were host, it doesn't show if the host country had any advantage.

2pts.


  1. Country success by sport / discipline / event (6pt)

The first radial graph is impossible to read. What does it represent? Percentage won by country in a category?
Usually, pie charts are a really bad idea (it was said during a lecture).

The second graph is not well titled. The ticks for the axis are overlayed between each others.

There is no way to know what the third graph represents.

3pts.


  1. Most successful athletes (6pt)

You made one dos for one data point. Seems wastefull.
Maybe you could have combined more athletes? It only shows one

3pts.


  1. Make two plots interactive (5pt)

Only one graph was made interactive. Why?

2.5pts.


  1. Data Table (2pt)

Ok.

2pts.


FORMAT (-5pt)

Please arrange your Github Folders. There should be only a folder named "Homewrok1" in your repo, plus a README file.
You didn't raised an issue for final submission.
No points will be taken because of Git or Github problems, but please come to office hours if you have questions.

You didn't save the images as instructed. There is no need to print ALL the data, makes the HTML impossible to browse.

PLEASE DONT PRINT THE DATA!!!!

-0pts.


Total Points: 19.5/38
Late policy: -0
Format: -0

Final grade: 19.5/38

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions